Impact vs Roll vs Cone Crushers

Posted in: , on 22. Feb. 2009 - 20:47

hi:

new to the forum, hello everybody.

question:

i have a small limestone crushing business, I am just getting equipment, i was woundering wich of these three crushers will produce the less fines; impact, roll cruhser or cone.

i am thinking about the roll, is the cheaper one. but i need to know how much fines it will produce. the material will be use for landscaping so cubicity wont matter.

thank you

Doci1
(not verified)

Re: Impact Vs Roll Vs Cone Crushers

Erstellt am 21. Apr. 2009 - 04:55

hi,

roller crusher (produce the less fines material)

cone crusher

impact crusher (produce the more fines material)

BR

Re: Impact Vs Roll Vs Cone Crushers

Erstellt am 11. Jun. 2009 - 07:14

A toothed roll crusher should be able to give you less fines than the other listed equipment. The impactor will give you the most fines and a cone should be somewhere in between.

Depending on the characteristics(UCS/Wi/Size) of the "Limestone" that you are talking about, the Toothed Roll Crusher may not be able to handle it. The limiting factor will be your UCS definitely.

What is your desired feed and product sizes?

Limestone Crushing

Erstellt am 19. Apr. 2014 - 03:19

Limestone crushing:

if it is soft non abrasive limestone, it can be nicely done with an IMPACTOR, HSI or VSI type no problem but, the key you will be, how many TPH you need, if just for a small amount of limestone screenings for use in landscaping jobs......YOU will not need a big TPH CRUSHER.

THE feed to and the conveying from and screening into a preferred size after will also dictate what you would buy and why.

A cone crusher is used as normal as HSI impact type crushers in soft limestone and do produce LESS FINES typically than an impactor.

both those crushers will produce a nice cubical product.

ROLL CRUSHER: WILL produce a nice cubical product but, welding on roll shells can become somewhat tedious, time consuming and a headache. less FINES here also.

George Baker

MODERATOR


Quote Originally Posted by fitofernandezView Post
hi:

new to the forum, hello everybody.

question:

i have a small limestone crushing business, I am just getting equipment, i was woundering wich of these three crushers will produce the less fines; impact, roll cruhser or cone.

i am thinking about the roll, is the cheaper one. but i need to know how much fines it will produce. the material will be use for landscaping so cubicity wont matter.

thank you

Best Regards, George Baker Regional Sales Manager - Canada TELSMITH Inc Mequon, WI 1-519-242-6664 Cell E: (work) [email]gbaker@telsmith.com[/email] E: (home) [email] gggman353@gmail.com[/email] website: [url]www.telsmith.com[/url] Manufacturer of portable, modular and stationary mineral processing equipment for the aggregate and mining industries.