Plough scraper for material discharge

Posted in: , on 29. Jul. 2004 - 16:46

I need to design feeding arrangement ( one at atime) to multiple bunkers.There is restriction of headroom. I can not place movable tripper conveyor. I can not install shuttle conveyor as headroom is not available to accomodate feeding conveyor to shuttle conveyor. I may bring the incoming conveyor itself on top of the bunkers route it along all the four bunkers and use retractible type scraper ( V plough or angular) on the conveyor at locations where material is to be discharged on bunker. The scraper would normally be kept up in idle position allowing material to pass through and interfere with next lowered scraper. In case material need to be discharged scraper will be lowered and fixed to that position till material fill up the bunker. The scraper shuld be motor/cylinder/coil operated for remote operation. With this I can manage within available headroom. Please comment upon the acceptability of the system or what better alternative can be thought.

Re: Plough Scraper For Material Discharge

Erstellt am 29. Jul. 2004 - 11:03

debashisde:

Although I agree that a shuttle conveyor would be an acceptable answer to your problem, you state that you do not have sufficient headroom for a transfer mechanism.

Possibilities include:

1) Using a shuttle conveyor that has a very shallow feed chute from the feed conveyor, or no chute at all. The shuttle must run faster than the feed belt.

2) Turn your feed conveyor into a combination feed/shuttle conveyor. This will require an automatic horizontal or vertical belt storage (take-up) arrangement at some point where there is space.

3) Use plows at the unload stations with a retractable belt straightening mechanism to remove the belt trough for unloading purposes. (This is possible but is both messy and unecessarily complex.)

4) Use a retractable belt tipper mechanism at the first three discharge points. I've seen this used in Saudi Arabia for iron ore - it is messy and hard on the belt.

5) Use an enclosed belt system, such as the Enerka one, which can be opened for discharge purposes and closed for general conveyance. This is a clean approach and has been used for similar purposes.

These are possibilities that come immediately to mind and doubtless there are many other possibilities.

Good luck with your research.

Dave Miller ADM Consulting 10668 Newbury Ave., N.W., Uniontown, Ohio 44685 USA Tel: 001 330 265 5881 FAX: 001 330 494 1704 E-mail: admconsulting@cs.com

Re: Plough Scraper For Material Discharge

Erstellt am 30. Jul. 2004 - 11:27

Mr Dave Miller, I would like to know the possibilities of carrying it pneumatically. The material is sponge iron with 1.7T/CuM Bulk Density. Particle size 6 to 15mm, the distance horizontal 50m from ground hopper vertical rise 8M. carrying rate 25 T/Hr. The conveying being single point feeding to multiple point discharge pressure conveying would be ideal.Installation of diverter valves at discharge points,the air separation at multiple discharge points and guiding through single vent filter may be complicated. Is there reference of any similar installation?

Pl furnish your valued suggestion.


Originally posted by ADM Consulting

debashisde:

Although I agree that a shuttle conveyor would be an acceptable answer to your problem, you state that you do not have sufficient headroom for a transfer mechanism.

Possibilities include:

1) Using a shuttle conveyor that has a very shallow feed chute from the feed conveyor, or no chute at all. The shuttle must run faster than the feed belt.

2) Turn your feed conveyor into a combination feed/shuttle conveyor. This will require an automatic horizontal or vertical belt storage (take-up) arrangement at some point where there is space.

3) Use plows at the unload stations with a retractable belt straightening mechanism to remove the belt trough for unloading purposes. (This is possible but is both messy and unecessarily complex.)

4) Use a retractable belt tipper mechanism at the first three discharge points. I've seen this used in Saudi Arabia for iron ore - it is messy and hard on the belt.

5) Use an enclosed belt system, such as the Enerka one, which can be opened for discharge purposes and closed for general conveyance. This is a clean approach and has been used for similar purposes.

These are possibilities that come immediately to mind and doubtless there are many other possibilities.

Good luck with your research.

Re: Plough Scraper For Material Discharge

Erstellt am 30. Jul. 2004 - 11:50

debashisde:

It may be possible, but I have very limited experience with pneumatic systems. I suggest that you e-mail Dr. David Mills, who moderates the Pneumatic Conveyer forum. He is an expert in those systems.

You can e-mail him by clicking on his name that is located on the Pneumatic Conveyor row and Moderator column; and then clicking on the e-mail link once his profile block appears.

Alternatively, you may want to start a thread in the pneumatic conveyor forum. If you do, include the details that you put in with your last input. With this low tonnage, I would have focused on the Becker-Enerka or Sicon Roulund systems over shuttles or other open belt options.

Regards,

Dave Miller ADM Consulting 10668 Newbury Ave., N.W., Uniontown, Ohio 44685 USA Tel: 001 330 265 5881 FAX: 001 330 494 1704 E-mail: admconsulting@cs.com

Re: Plough Scraper For Material Discharge

Erstellt am 30. Jul. 2004 - 02:39

The plow arrangement you desribe is quite often done in the foundry industry for multiple discharge points. Some suggestions should you decide to go this route:

1. A full support bed should be placed under each plow to allow as much material to be scraped from the belt with plow as possible. Our Guard-A-Seal (CR) support beds work great for this.

2. A means to accept the small amount of material that will not be removed by the plow should be placed at the end of the belt.

3. Additional horsepower may be required due to the plows and support beds.

4. The belt can be flat, but containment skirtboards with dust seal should be placed along the discharge area.

Larry J. Goldbeck Martin Engineering

Re: Plough Scraper For Material Discharge

Erstellt am 2. Aug. 2004 - 07:27

Dear Shri debashishde,

You may use the plough if you wish, however, you have to keep the belt speed very low. Multi-point discharge ploughs are often used for foundry sand discharge. You have to also accept the wear of belt and plough.

In the event if the conveyor and system is to operate round the clock, then shuttle conveyor or tripper is used. The plough can give satisfactory result when system is to operate continuously and if the material is relatively less abrasive. Generally, such arrangement is not preferred in heavy class application such as power station etc.

Regards,

Ishwar G Mulani.

Author of Book : Engineering Science and Application Design for Belt Conveyors.

Advisor / Consultant for Bulk Material Handling System & Issues.

Email : parimul@pn2.vsnl.net.in

Tel.: 0091 (0)20 25882916

Plaogh Scraper

Erstellt am 5. Aug. 2004 - 10:36

Gentlemen

Dear mr debashisde

10 years ago I made a project with plough scrapers to discharge coal to 12 siloes in a large power plant.

The belt width was 1200 mm and the capacity was 1000 t/hour.

coal - 100 mm. In full load period it was conveying 12-13000 tonnes pr 24 hours.

The belt was flattened by a sliding plate under the belt, lifted by a hydraulic system. Ths plough vas altso hydraulic lifted but was pressed against the belt by its own weight.

The plough consists of 3 scraper systems.

1. -A pre scraper, taking the main amount of material and not toughting the belt.

2. - A main scraper profile in PE running against the belt, removing the rest material.

3. - A final scraper in PUR cleaning the belt for fines.

The belt was cleaned 99 % only dust was remained.

The wear of the belt was not more than a knife scaper would do at the drive drum, and the power consumption was messured to app 1,5 kw pro plough ( under estimation)

The wery interesting thing about this plough system was that it saved time compared to the shuttle belt, used before this installation.

They had to stop the conveying during the moving of the shuttle belt,between the siloes.

Now they could shift between the siloes with full belt capacity,and so keep a higher conveying rate pro hour.

EP Design og Teknik Erik Petersen Farverhus 14A 6200 Aabenraa, Denmark Tlf 7462 0720 Fax 7462 0760 www.EP-design.dk Mail: siri@post10.tele.dk

Re: Plough Scraper For Material Discharge

Erstellt am 6. Aug. 2004 - 01:09

Dear Debashisde, Erik and Associates,

I know this sounds like me too. I am just confirming what Erik is saying.

In 1977, I designed and installed a petroleum coke V-plow that cut 400t/h x -150 mm lump off the conveyor. Like Erik, the belt was elevated by a flat platen to allow the plow to bifricate the load into chutes on either side of the belt. The conveyor was running at about 2 m/s and was about 1067mm wide by my memory.

A stainless steel V plow (45 degree angles) first stage blade was used. The V-plow was raked into the flow stream about 45 degrees similar to a train's cow catcher. The plow had a self-relieving center to edge at about 6 degree bias. The first blade removed all material above the 40x80 mm gap.

A vertical, polyethylene vee was used for the second blade. It was placed about 250 mm behind the primary blade and had a 50 degree vee angle to the belt. Enough space has to be allowed between blades to transport the remaining material passing below the first blade's gap, factoring for belt speed.

The third blade was made of a series of blades to remove spittle and dust by sucessive discharge and displacement. The blades overlaped and were individually articulated. They were vertical to the belt.

For what its worth.

Lawrence Nordell

www.conveyor-dynamics.com

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450
Vivek
(not verified)

Re: Plough Scraper For Material Discharge

Erstellt am 6. Aug. 2004 - 12:30

Debasis,

u can even think of moving head discharge.

i.e. by providing a loop of exra belt near disc pulley, locating drive suitably and mounting disc.pulley with chute on some sliding mechanism, you can discharge to 4 bunkers.

it has not been practiced till now for such a case but is feasible.

vivek

Plough Scraper

Erstellt am 7. Aug. 2004 - 07:48

Dear debasishde,

Retractable plow scrappers are qute common and looks like the ideal solution against the constraints you have referred.Please take care that your belt speed should be quite low-say, 1M/sec-and,provide a conservative top cover thickness.

Regards,

diptasmallick

Scrapper In Sponge Iron

Erstellt am 13. Aug. 2004 - 02:27

dear friend.

we used scrappers in sponge iron in the pt krakatoasteel plant in indonesia as a temporary measure for storage reoxidation fire fighting.

It worked well , some material though bypasses the plough and remains in the belt. being the particles pellets this is hard to avoid as the particle rolls in contact with the belt linning the scraopper.

Just consider a final position wher you can dump the material remaining on the belt.

otherwise you will do ok.

marco

TECMEN Consultant in: Sponge Iron (DRI) handling Sponge Iron DRI Automated Storage Firefighting and Root Cause Analysis Pneumatic Conveying Consultants Phone 5281 8300 4456.
eleveyor
(not verified)

Conveyor Ploughs

Erstellt am 13. Aug. 2004 - 04:02

We designed a simple V-type belt plough (plow) for use with our sludge conveyors and have been applying this for years quite successfully. We use a linear actuator for remote activation.

If you would like us to look at your application, please send all relevant details. We'll tell you whether ours will work for you.

Werner Plaut

EleVeyor Services, Inc.

NithinNarayanan
(not verified)

Plough Scraper

Erstellt am 15. Aug. 2004 - 05:22

I have recently installed a similar plough feeder for iron ore . The performance was not good because of excessive spillage. As suggested by our other friends I suggest you should think of shuttle feeder if you are looking for a trouble free solution

R.Narayanan

Bangalore

eleveyor
(not verified)

Plough Feeders

Erstellt am 16. Aug. 2004 - 05:36

There are plough feeders and plough feeders. Not all are the same design or effectiveness. If we approve of the application, we'll guarantee the operation of our system.

W. Plaut

EleVeyor Services, Inc.

Ploug Diverter

Erstellt am 16. Aug. 2004 - 06:00

dear Friend

This is a simple enough application, try it yourself.

if you use singlke blade plough you will excert a lateral force in your belt, but that can be tolerable.

If you ise a v sape plough . you need a larger discharge hopper.

I have installed both types, with and without secondary blades.

If your material is large and can wedge below the scrapper, consider spring loadig it to reduce damage to your conveyor.

Use a dumb bin at the head pulley to pick up the leftovers.

If there a possibility of metal pieces to be carried over with your feed . Consider a magnetic pickup.

Do not be afraid , try it yourself , observe and modify as needed.

Do not iuse pistons in your first try use an articulated lever.

If you do not have access to the field test.

Then buy it from an external supplier. The poassibilities of being right in the first try if you haven¨t done it before are not good.

Rgards

marco

TECMEN Consultant in: Sponge Iron (DRI) handling Sponge Iron DRI Automated Storage Firefighting and Root Cause Analysis Pneumatic Conveying Consultants Phone 5281 8300 4456.
NithinNarayanan
(not verified)

Plough Feeder

Erstellt am 16. Aug. 2004 - 07:12

Mr. Marco has summed it up correctly."The poassibilities of being right in the first try if you haven¨t done it before are not good."

I fully agree.

If you have to try and make the plough feeder work Go ahead and get started.

Specific problems that you may encounter can be attended to . But your client should be cooperative and bear with you till then

When made successful this will be a good solution

RNarayanan

Multiple Diverters Off One Conveyor

Erstellt am 19. Sep. 2004 - 01:03

We have designed a unit that is suitable for your application and can be PLC controled. The bed will lift from being a trough and flatten to a flat deck. In this movement the blade is lowered automaticly. When lowered the blade is also raised allowing the product to pass. You may contact us for further details.

Frans van der Zee
(not verified)

Re: Plough Scraper For Material Discharge

Erstellt am 26. Jan. 2005 - 02:13

Dear Sir,

If you would like to know more about the Dunlop Enerka system, you can also visit our web site. www.enclosedbulk.com

We are the licencee of Fenner Dunlop for this system.

Best regards

Frans van der Zee

Enclosed Bulk Systems